Are you vulnerable to union organizing?
Take our 5-minute quiz to identify both internal and external factors that impact unionization – and get tips on how to become union-proof.
Are your leaders aligned with the company vision?
From Implicit Bias to Managing Change, your leaders need training that moves the company forward.
How engaged are your employees?
This free assessment will guide you to the right strategy to create employee advocates.
Management Consulting Services
Check out our proactive strategies that support positive employee relations.
Tagged with: Positive Employee Relations, Prevent Union Organizing
The once-staid automotive industry is transitioning into a modern era defined by the development of electric vehicles, increasingly sophisticated technology, constant supply chain issues, and a labor shortage propelled by demographic and economic turmoil. Though auto manufacturers are viewed as locked into unionization, the changing auto market is opening up opportunities for companies to operate non-union plants and supply chain businesses to keep their prices low by maintaining non-union workforces. During this transition period, labor relations become a significant factor in organizational success because engaged employees and their employers have a shared purpose. The following sections discuss the common labor relations issues in the automotive industry and the need to prepare now for the accelerating changes.
The major automotive companies are unionized and have been for decades. In fact, the automotive industry’s workforce has been comprised of what people think of as the stereotypical union worker. Auto manufacturing has employed workers as blue-collar as workers in the construction industry. The image of mostly men working production lines is one of America’s historical images. Notice the word “historical” because the auto manufacturing floor looks entirely different today as robotics and artificial intelligence manage many jobs that employees once handled.
The automotive industry has significantly changed, meaning its suppliers must adapt to remain competitive. Because the major auto manufacturing companies are unionized, which comes with increased labor and administrative costs, they are looking at two areas where they can manage costs: preventing unionization in new manufacturing plants producing tech-based vehicles like electric cars and managing costs in the supply chain. The automotive supply chain is large and complex because of the myriad of components and technologies that go into producing a vehicle, giving labor unions numerous targets.
Let’s first look at the common labor relations issues among automotive suppliers trying to manage their costs to remain competitive while maintaining a positive organizational culture and engaged workforce.
The COVID pandemic severely impacted the automotive industry workforce because remote work was impossible for most jobs. The massive decline in sales, made worse by component shortages like computer chips, led to layoffs and wage decreases. There is also significant uncertainty as the auto industry transitions to electric vehicles, requiring new manufacturing plants and components, new skills and fewer employees. Lack of job security is a significant driver for low employee engagement and a common labor union issue.
A 100-page discussion on supply chain issues could be written. From a labor relations perspective, automotive suppliers are dealing with some of the following situations:
Pursuing skilled workers and workers with technology knowledge who can be successfully trained requires automotive companies to be flexible. Employee attitudes toward manufacturing work have changed, and employers need to adapt through flexibility.
The Manufacturer’s Alliance Foundation’s research found that manufacturers need to offer flex time, split shifts, part-time work, and swap shifts to attract and retain workers. “Unions used to negotiate simple forms of this, but the kind of flexibility demanded today is way beyond the shop steward deciding who gets the overtime.” Knowledge workers can work remotely, but how do you entice a new generation of workers to choose a production job requiring onsite work?
The Foundation says manufacturers will have to offer some of the same things that IT workers enjoy. It suggests cross-training, assembling smaller teams, and eliminating direct management control over task completion (employee autonomy). Workers should be able to get the work done without the need for specific hardline scheduling and have the flexibility to add extra shifts for personal reasons, help a coworker, or take an afternoon off to care for family members.
The law firm Foley & Lardner wrote, "In the current environment, with inflation and significant price volatility, suppliers (and OEMs) are rethinking the traditional structure for component contracts. Long-term contracts at a fixed, or even declining, price may no longer be practical." Suppliers are likely to begin negotiating shorter contracts which could help them avoid unexpected layoffs through better pricing control.
It’s difficult for employers to commit to long-term wage and benefit increases when price volatility is triggered by events like global supply chain backlogs, increasingly scarce resources, government regulations, inflation, and the transitioning automotive industry. A related issue is that the utilization of a lean, just-in-time inventory management strategy has led to excessive overtime to expedite shipments and shutdowns due to inventory shortages. These actions attract labor unions looking for employees experiencing burnout, loss of job security, and other human resources issues.
Since auto manufacturers have been unionized for decades, the pro-union government often presents them as proof that unions are good. For example, President Biden visited Milwaukee’s Labor Fest for the 2022 Labor Day, and most of his speech concerned labor unions, saying they built the middle class. At the September 2022 Detroit Auto Show, he spoke to union workers, including United Auto Workers (UAW), praising union workers as a reliable labor investment and saying that union labor is quality and long-lasting. These are just two examples. The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) is advancing the pro-labor agenda through its decision-making authority and changing labor laws through bureaucratic decision-making.
All of the factors just discussed impact labor relations, making prioritization of employee engagement crucial to long-term success. Employee engagement not only plays a role in employee retention; it influences the employee experience and performance and the organizational culture. As the automotive industry continues to embrace digital and innovation, the entire industry, including automakers, original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) and original design manufacturers (ODM), must adapt and change.
Labor relations is concerned with preventing and resolving employee problems that arise from work performance and is also focused on developing a positive organizational culture. The labor relations expert is skilled in improving employee relationships through:
If there is a union, the labor relations expertise includes negotiating and administering collective bargaining agreements and consulting with the union representative.
What may be missed is the fact that positive employee engagement makes a difference in employer branding, which in turn impacts the ability to attract skilled labor. In addition, the automotive industry is going through many changes simultaneously, one of them being the push for electric vehicles (EVs). Future manufacturing plants or facilities may prevent union organizing even though labor unions are deeply embedded in the big automotive companies. Employers who can meet the needs of the younger generation in terms of schedule flexibility, benefits, employee voice, interesting tech work, etc., will make a union unnecessary.
What keeps the automotive industry leaders up at night concerning labor relations and labor unions? What does labor relations consulting in the automotive industry deliver? Bottom line: Consultants solve problems.
IRI Consultants offers clients in the automotive industry unique qualifications. The company’s roots are in Michigan, and it was established when the Big Three automakers dominated the automotive industry. With over 40 years of labor relations consulting in the automotive sector, IRI Consultants:
What can labor relations consulting in the automotive industry do for automotive companies? First, let’s briefly discuss the impact of electric vehicle production and unions. The labor unions have been concerned about the country moving too fast to produce electric vehicles. The unions fear electric vehicle production would require fewer workers because the cars don’t have engines to assemble and require significantly fewer parts. Another fear was that the union would lose thousands of potential union jobs when new electric-vehicle related plants were built.
For example, Ford announced it’s building four factories in Kentucky and Tennessee. Three are for electric vehicles. Locating them in the South was a concern because they are both right-to-work states. To overcome the union resistance, Ford announced it would invest billions of dollars in producing electric vehicles in the Midwest, creating 6,000 union jobs. Ford also agreed to convert 3,000 temporary jobs to permanent full-time positions before the date the UAW contract expired.
The economic analysts and the UAW agreed that the government would have to help support the electric vehicle industry. The Inflation Reduction Act allows for a $7,500 consumer tax credit if the passenger vehicles are assembled in North America and if specific rules concerning materials and components for EV batteries are met. So much politics is involved. The idea is that some vehicle manufacturing would come home to the U.S., and union workers would get hired. The UAW spent $1.25 million to support federal candidates in the 2020 elections, and 99 percent were Democrats. In February 2022, the U.S. Departments of Transportation and Energy announced they were spending $5 billion to create a network of EV charging stations per the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law.
When General Motors announced it had set a goal to produce only battery-powered vehicles by 2035 with the exclusion of heavier trucks, unions started worrying. First, workers will need to learn new skills. Second, as mentioned, fewer workers are required to produce electric vehicles. Union workers making transmissions and engines for gas-powered vehicles are particularly vulnerable. A UAW paper said Ford and Volkswagen executives expect EVs to reduce the labor hours needed to produce a vehicle by 30 percent. General Motors must negotiate a new union contract in 2023, and top issues include wages and job security. Battery manufacturing is considered a parts-supply function that pays a lower wage.
Preparing now for the accelerating changes in the automotive industry is important to preventing union organizing or managing union negotiations. Elon Musk, CEO of Tesla, challenged the UAW to try organizing his employees at the Fremont, CA, plant. He tweeted, “Our real challenge is Bay Area has negative unemployment, so if we don’t treat and compensate our (awesome) people well, they have many other offers and will just leave! I’d like hereby to invite UAW to hold a union vote at their convenience. Tesla will do nothing to stop them.”
At the heart of his message is that positive employee relations, fair pay, employee voice, and the other ways employers treat workers will determine how much inroads a labor union can make. As the automotive industry, including its supply chain, continues to manage continuous disruption and a transition to electric vehicle production, the time is ripe for each business to bring in a labor relations consultant who can assist management with determining how to strengthen positive employee relations, employee engagement, and employee voice.
Each company should consider the impact of automation and going digital, determine how it can accommodate employee needs for flexibility and improved benefits, add hiring and work incentives, and develop cross-training programs for skills upgrading for better recruitment and retention. It begins with leadership training. Gallup found that the manager accounts for 70 percent of team engagement variance, and said, “The manager-employee relationship is the most important relationship at every stage of the employee journey.”
What do the executives in the automotive supply chain say about talent management? The Q4 2022 OESA Automotive Supplier Barometer Index (SBI) measures the sentiments of North American automotive supplier executives. The fourth quarter SBI focused on HR and talent and found:
Creating a great employee experience now is just the beginning of a strategic plan for meeting employee needs now and in the future. IRI Consultants offers labor relations consulting in the automotive industry that can help your company make a union unnecessary, even as the industry disruptions continue as expected.